Male Vs Female Employment in the Fashion Industry

The 'paradox' of working in the earth'south most equal countries

(Paradigm credit:

Getty Images

)

Even Europe's nearly egalitarian countries struggle to put women on an even basis at work. In the Nordics, why do women still lag backside men in pay, direction and company ownership?

W

When Bolette Wrestroem moved back to Denmark afterwards spending near of her twenties overseas, she was excited to experience the "gender equality" for which the Nordic region is globally famous. At offset, she wasn't disappointed.

"I definitely think Denmark is more than open up-minded than all the other places I take lived," says the 28-twelvemonth-old, at present a customs manager for a Copenhagen start-up. "At that place is more focus on what y'all are capable of, instead of your gender."

But amidst immersion in a culture that seemed to actively champion women's rights, she couldn't escape the fact that there were still "primarily white males sitting at the peak" of many of the all-time-known companies. Denmark's global image, versus the reality, "didn't always match up".

It is a paradox that many women working in the Nordics volition recognise.

The region has a glowing reputation equally the best place in the globe when it comes to gender equality, cheers to welfare states that back up working families and promote parental go out, and legal, political and cultural back up for the goal of gender equality.

But many experts argue that progress has flatlined, suggesting these countries are further from achieving equality than global observers might imagine.

"We practise have the idea of being gender equal…but we have a long manner to go before nosotros are gender equal," argues Anneli Häyren, a researcher at the Centre for Gender Research at Uppsala University in Sweden. "I recall information technology will have quite a lot of time - another 50 years at least - until nosotros get there - and that is only if we keep working at it."

For Bolette Wrestroem, Denmark's global image as a leader in gender equality "didn't always friction match upward" with the reality in the workplace (Credit: Bolette Wrestroem)

Drinking glass ceilings

Strong progress has been made in the public sector; in Sweden more than women than men currently hold management positions in this sphere. In politics, 46% of Swedish members of parliament are women, while the proportion in other Nordic countries is around 40%.

However, there are notwithstanding surprisingly few women in senior individual sector roles. Just  28% of managers in Denmark are female, rising to 32% in Finland and Norway, and 36% in Sweden, according to a written report past independent think tank The Cato Institute in 2018. Iceland is the highest-scoring Nordic country, with twoscore%. But that is nonetheless three points behind the The states, where 43% of managers are women, despite the US ranking just 51 in the World Economic Forum's Gender Gap index.

Strong concerns most this disparity were raised last year in The Nordic Gender Consequence at Work, a report from the Nordic Council of Ministers, an advisory body. The writers found "a troubling pattern" in businesses - "the higher up the hierarchy y'all look, the more than men you will see".

"It feels more equal than in the U.s., because people are more than focused and consistent in talking near the topic...But I am non certain they are always held accountable in terms of upholding those ethics," agrees Dani Nguyen, 31, an executive recruiter based in the Swedish uppercase who previously worked in Silicon Valley.

When it comes to pay, the difference betwixt gross average hourly earnings of male and female employees in Kingdom of denmark, Iceland and Norway is but slightly below the EU average of 16%. In Republic of finland the figure creeps to 16.7%. Sweden comes out best with 12.three%, but still lags behind Luxembourg, Italian republic and Romania, which all manage a pay gap of 5% or less.

Meanwhile, women in the Nordics trail their male counterparts in alluring investment for new businesses. Only 1% of investments registered in the Nordic Tech List database terminal twelvemonth went to companies headed solely by female founders, according to figures analysed past Swedish business news site DI Digital.

"Information technology is definitely a problem," says Rikke Eckhoff Høvding, CEO of industry trunk The Norwegian Venture Capital and Private Equity Clan (NVCA).  "It is easier to get VC funding if you are male. Nosotros have had this word a lot in the final few years and everyone is request 'what we tin can do side by side?'."

Rikke Eckhoff Hovding says inspiring role models of female person leadership are still really important for making progress (Credit: Sigmund Sagberg Andersen)

Why has progress stalled?

Gender experts and campaigners are at odds over why the region continues to face up these disparities.

1 common explanation is that women are more likely than men to cull public sector careers. This contributes to the pay gap (public sector jobs tend to pay less) and limits the puddle of female talent available for pinnacle private sector roles. But the reasons women tend to pick these careers remain up for debate.

Last twelvemonth, researchers in the The states and UK found that countries with an existing culture of gender equality take an fifty-fifty smaller proportion of women taking degrees in science, applied science and mathematics (STEM).

"It is a paradox … nobody would have expected this to be the reality of our fourth dimension," says Professor Gijsbert Stoet, i of the written report's authors.

He argues that since Nordic countries have a mostly high standard of living and strong welfare states, immature women are gratuitous to pick careers based on their own interests, which he says are often more probable to include working in care-giving roles or with languages. By dissimilarity, high achievers in less stable economies might choose STEM careers based on the income and security they provide, even if they prefer other areas.

"Girls and boys are different, and have unlike preferences on the whole," he argues. He believes besides much media focus is placed on the lack of women in CEO positions, since these account for such a small proportion of jobs overall, and suggests that more men fill these roles since "the personality traits and ambition to be important and famous is higher in men than women".

But others strongly believe that social conditioning is the major driver when information technology comes to women'southward career choices and promotion opportunities, and stress that gender stereotypes persist.

"I don't remember information technology's about selection, it'due south well-nigh structures … to say information technology's about choice is to 'blame the victim'," says Anneli Häyren at the Eye for Gender Research at Uppsala Academy.

She argues that men remain better paid due to a greater value being placed on management positions and in certain sectors, such as tech and science, which are "male-gendered", in contrast to "female-gendered" jobs focused on caregiving. She says men in professions like preschool educational activity or nursing usually find information technology easier to climb these career ladders than women entering "male-gendered" areas. "It is a waterproof sign of how strong the patriarchy is," she argues.

Häyren too rejects the idea that women in the Nordics are less ambitious than men. "Research suggests it is ofttimes a strategic decision not to apply for certain roles…Women do want (it), but they realise that they won't get it."

The employment rate for women in the Nordic region is 72%, compared to an average of 59% beyond developed western countries (Credit: Getty Images)

Work-life balance

Juggling a career with family life remains a challenge for some women in the Nordics, despite policies like subsidised childcare and flexible working hours encouraging couples to share parenting.

While Nordic fathers do take more parental leave than anywhere else in the world, the gender carve up of parenting labour remains far from equal. In Iceland and Sweden - which accept the most generous policies - almost 30% of leave is taken by fathers, while in Norway the figure is simply over 19%, and the proportion drops to 11% in Denmark and Finland, co-ordinate to The Nordic Gender Effect at Work report.

The report also flags two ongoing challenges; women are more than probable to work function-time and they invest more hours in housework or caring for elderly relatives than men. Many who can afford help cull non to, because at that place is a degree of stigma attached to outsourcing household chores in Scandinavia. Fifty-fifty the region'south most high-profile influencer and businesswoman, Isabella Löwengrip, faced criticism when she hired a personal assistant subsequently divorcing her hubby.

"Men are more active in family life...But women still feel split up between work and home and beingness a adept parent - even though we are not in the 1950s anymore," reflects Anette Tvedergaard Madsen, 45, who has 3 children and holds a senior marketing office at one of Denmark's largest banks.

Madsen argues that most Nordic companies recognise the benefits of a various workforce and its importance when it comes to employer branding. "Yous want to be a modernistic organisation and an bonny workplace by creating diversity - not simply male and female but as well different nationalities," she says.

But the marketing strategist believes that unconscious biases can bear on senior hiring decisions.

"Men are definitely not trying to avoid women in top positions," she argues, just "who they know best and who is sitting next to them" continues to play a role, likewise as protecting their own reputations.

Stockholm-based recruiter Dani Nguyen agrees. "Fifty-fifty in Sweden in that location is something of an 'quondam boys club', she argues. "The corporate environment has been built past white men and for white men."

Denmark and Sweden recently scored tiptop marks in a World Bank study of how much laws limit discrimination in employment and entrepreneurship (Credit: Getty Images)

What can be washed?

Campaigners are proposing a wide range of solutions to move forrad, including calls for private company targets for senior managers or nationwide quotas. "If this isn't a KPI (central operation indicator) the business is held answerable for, it becomes a side hobby and side hobbies aren't e'er invested in financially or time wise," argues Nguyen.

But critics of fixed targets argue that the concept could devalue the way women hired under this regime are perceived in the workplace. Danish showtime-up community managing director Bolette Wrestroem says quotas, while potentially a "good stepping-stone", could likewise suggest that "women are merely there because it is required and not because of their skills or capabilities".

Quotas for lath members accept already been introduced on a nationwide scale in Norway and Iceland. Only every bit The Nordic Gender Result at Work report points out, improvements at lath level accept not led to a leap in the number of women CEOs or managers. "One reason for this is that the business concern world is characterised by a broad range of leadership standards and traits that are typically (peradventure stereotypically) associated with men," information technology concludes.

Nguyen says she has placed several women in high positions in Swedish head offices who ended upwardly leaving because they felt they needed to adapt too much to be heard. "The about important stride is creating an environment where people of different backgrounds, ethnicity, gender, faith, sexuality, feel empowered and supported to exercise their best," she argues. "We cannot just hire females and minorities and expect them to figure it out."

Many campaigners debate that educating male employees on the benefits of diversity should be more prominent. Numerous global studies accept concluded that there is a positive correlation between the presence of women in leadership roles and an organisation's operation.

The principal executive of Heba, a Stockholm rental visitor named-and-shamed for low male-female person diversity, recently made headlines for albeit he hadn't idea well-nigh the advantages of having more women managers until his top executive squad achieved gender residual.

"I thought competence was the main thing - competence and attitude - not sex, but I've changed my mind. The workplace works meliorate because of the [gender] mix," Lennart Karlsson told the BBC before long afterwards. "The discussion climate is better, you have a better conversation and a better understanding for each other."

In Norway, a private disinterestedness firm criticised for a lack of female person managers recently introduced a policy making it mandatory for all fathers to take at least two months' parental get out, or chance losing their bonus, to help reduce unconscious bias.

"If I am a female person and I expect at the male squad members effectually me becoming fathers and none of them take any parental leave, I volition feel that I am an outlier when I go pregnant and I demand my parental leave," says Master Operating Officer Morten Welo. "So we thought - 'let'due south plough this effectually', and say information technology'south mandatory regardless of gender."

He says the policy also sends "an of import bespeak" that he hopes will encourage more young female graduates to consider the visitor. "To attract the best talent, nosotros demand amend diversity."

More companies are also experimenting with digital platforms designed to help tackle unconscious biases. Tengai, the globe's get-go robot designed to acquit out unbiased job interviews, is being tested by major Swedish recruitment firm TNG. In Norway, Equality Check, a community-based platform of employee reviews rating equality in companies (like to the English language-language Glassdoor platform), has go a popular tool for both applicants and Hr professionals.

"Large funds have also become a lot more aware of how they write job descriptions - what words you use and how practice yous behave the interview processes," adds Rikke Eckhoff Høvding at the Norwegian Venture Capital and Individual Disinterestedness Clan (NVCA). "I would say no-1 knows the answers, then we demand to endeavour different things, readjust and think of something new if it doesn't work."

Charlotte Sundåker and Linda Waxin launched thinktank Ownershift, which aims to broaden word around greater gender equality through ownership (Credit: Maddy Savage)

Finding role models

On a political level, all the Nordic governments are working to tackle the gender gap.

Final year Iceland became the first land in the world to require companies with 25 or more workers to demonstrate that they pay men and women equally for the same work, with daily fines for firms that fail to do so.

Finland'due south new Working Hours Act, due to come into force in 2020, will requite the majority of full-time employees the correct to make up one's mind when and where they work for at to the lowest degree half of their working hours, in a move designed to help boost flexibility.

Initiatives in Sweden include the recent launch of the Gender Equality Agency, designed to promote better coordination on the issue, and coding lessons for children, partly aimed at tackling early biases in terms of tech-based career choices.

Meanwhile, many campaigners concord that grassroots efforts designed to empower women on an individual level remain essential. "Function models are really important. It'due south hard to exist what you lot can't see," argues Rikke Eckhoff Høvding. "But you can visualise a career path and take risks if you see others who accept taken that path."

She says that the start-up community in Scandinavia is already making strides in this area, through run into-ups, conferences and networking events targeting the gender gap. "Female founders are very keen to promote other female founders," she argues.

Two successful Swedish female entrepreneurs - Charlotte Sundåker and Linda Waxin - recently launched Ownershift, an independent retrieve tank designed to expand discussions well-nigh gender equality to include ownership and risk-taking. In Sweden, men still own roughly double what women own in terms of upper-case letter, land, existent estate, forests and natural resources.

"We think that if more women create their own structures and companies, the overall structure will modify into more than empathic systems," says Sundåker.

Staying in the spotlight

For Anneli Häyren, at the Middle for Gender Research in Uppsala, a key goal is only to ensure that public discussions near gender equality continue, both in Nordic nations and on a global scale.

"On some level information technology really striking the brakes," she says of public discourse in recent years. "Quite a lot of people think nosotros have discussed information technology plenty and it is a dead argue."

Simply she believes that raising awareness of the ongoing challenges in Sweden and the Nordics is essential, so that the region tin pick up the pace of change and continue to inspire the earth.

Share this post